Jay Nelsestuen is a Tucson native who has been singing since he could speak, much to the consternation of his school teachers. Through middle and high school he developed and cultivated a love for choral music, spending hours in his room creating multi-track recordings, singing along to famous choirs like The Sixteen, Voces8, and Tenebrae, training his ear to fit his voice seamlessly into any ensemble. This, together with piano lessons from the age of 9, meant he was destined to be a musician.
Not content merely to sing or play great music, he set out to become a composer himself, earning a Bachelor of Music degree in Composition from The Master’s University in 2020. His compositions and arrangements have been internationally performed, by church and secular choirs alike. In 2015, at the age of 17, he answered a call for scores by the British choir Sansara, who sought pieces set to the poetry of W.B. Yeats. His setting of A Faery Song was performed that year at Queen’s College, Oxford. In 2019, The Master’s Chorale performed In The Eyes Of The Lord on their summer tour of northern California and the Pacific Northwest. His 2022 composition All’s Well was performed that year at the graduation exercises for Pusch Ridge Christian Academy, his alma mater, and in 2026 the Desert Skies United Methodist Choir commissioned and premiered a new choral anthem, Come Unto Me.
The Tucson Sunshine Chorus can claim to have recruited Jay before he knew it; while in high school, he attended a Youth In Harmony event, hosted jointly by TSC and the local SingUnited (formerly Sweet Adelines) chorus, Tucson Desert Harmony. In 2023, while seeking to join a singing community after coronavirus restrictions eased, he remembered the fun he had with “the barbershoppers” and visited a rehearsal. The chorus, recently deprived of their director and weakened by the coronavirus pandemic, eagerly sought to capitalize on his capable lead voice and his musical expertise, installing him as musical director in September 2024. Since then, his enthusiasm and dedication to the craft continue to grow the chorus and reestablish TSC as the leading men’s a cappella group in Tucson. He recently led the chorus to the Plateau A chorus championship at the Far Western District’s Arizona Division convention, where they also won Most Improved, and his quartet Resonance took home the Novice quartet championship. Turns out he has a knack for barbershop.
Outside of TSC, Jay continues to sing and learn from other experts in his field, lending his voice to several other community choral organizations across the Tucson and Phoenix areas, including the Phoenicians chorus (2024-2025), Arizona Repertory Singers (fall 2025), Neoteric Chamber Choir (spring 2026), and Helios Ensemble (2026-present). He has also competed with his Phoenix-based quartet, Banana Bread. When he’s not musicking, Jay loves to go hiking and enjoy the sunshine. You might also find him with a cup of coffee and a good book somewhere.